Hello dear
Welcome to Cafe Sarah
At Cafe Sarah, located in the charming North Creek, NY, we embrace the spirit of community and deliciousness. Our story is woven from the love of fresh pastries, expertly brewed coffee, and heartfelt customer service. From the aromatic pumpkin bread to the legendary grown-up grilled cheese, every dish celebrates quality and flavor. Guests enjoy a cozy atmosphere—ideal for enjoying a morning latte or grabbing a bite to go. With friendly staff and a lovely outdoor seating area, Cafe Sarah invites you to experience more than just food; it’s a gathering place where everyone feels welcome. Join us and savor the warmth!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Cafe Sarah
Welcome to the delightful world of Cafe Sarah, a charming haven situated at 260 Main St, North Creek, NY. This cozy establishment seamlessly blends the essence of a bakery, breakfast spot, and cafe, making it the perfect destination for locals and visitors alike.
Cafe Sarah has earned a stellar reputation for its delicious food and exquisite beverages. Customers rave about the fantastic espresso drinks, with many highlighting favorites like the lush pumpkin bread and the comforting grown-up grilled cheese sandwich. This cafe isn’t just about satisfying your hunger; it’s about offering a cozy atmosphere where everyone feels welcome.
- Quality Beverages: The iced latte has received glowing reviews for being "perfectly made," while their fresh baked pastries like blueberry muffins and cinnamon rolls are nothing short of delectable.
- Warm Ambiance: With a lovely view of the impressive 270-foot long North Creek Mosaic Project from the counter by the window, guests can savor their meals while soaking in the local art.
- Friendly Staff: The staff at Cafe Sarah is often praised for their friendliness, turning a simple visit into a memorable experience. A heartfelt "please" and "thank you" go a long way here.
This cafe not only serves excellent food, but it also fosters a sense of community. Many patrons return year after year, making it a beloved stop for those skiing at Gore Mountain. Although some guests have noted fluctuations in staff interactions, the overall consensus remains—you will enjoy quality food in a friendly environment.
Whether you're grabbing a snack on-the-go or settling in for a leisurely brunch, Cafe Sarah promises a delightful culinary experience that will keep you coming back for more. Don't miss out on the chance to visit this North Creek gem—your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Sarah's always gets everything right. It's delicious food and beverages, S well as on point customer service every timr ”
“ Fantastic espresso drinks! Favorite baked good - pumpkin bread! Favorite sandwich - grown-up grilled cheese! Sit at the counter by the window to look out at the 270 foot-long North Creek Mosaic Project! Best part of Cafe Sarah is the friendly staff - a simple please and thank you goes a long way! ”
“ While staying in North Creek for a vacation we visited this cafe twice. The iced latte I got both times was perfectly made. The pastries - a blueberry muffin and chocolate zucchini bread - were super fresh and delicious. My 10-year old said this was the best muffin she's ever had. And I bought Thai peanut noodles salad to go - so good! A great little place - I recommend! ”
“ Yummy pastries at this spot. Fresh baked muffins and cinnamon rolls, so delicious . Great coffee too and super friendly service. ”
“ My family and I visited this town two years in a row for skiing at Gore Mountain. Both times we got breakfast at Café Sarah. While the food remained delicious, there was definitely a mood shift between the first year and the second. In the first year, the staff was very friendly, happy, and even excited to see our two dogs, inviting them in for a treat. The second (this) year, there was a downshift in the atmosphere. The stuff was still nice, but the warm excitement was no longer present. We were also (politely) told to please leave the dogs outside (some members of our group had started to come in with them), as there were people dining indoors. I get it, and it makes sense that they don't want to be penalized and want to maintain a healthy environment for all (plus, last year, there was limited-to-no indoor dining at the café)-- it was just a drastic difference. We definitely would still return, if we come skiing at Gore again. As I said, the food is tasty, and the staff was never anything but polite. Just leave the dogs at home. The shit to energy may have just been from busy/slow season stress, in which case we hope all remains well at Café Sarah! ”
“ Wonderful little spot! Great for fresh bread, breakfast/lunch sandwiches and coffee! Right in town and very affordable, easy to stop by and grab something before a hike! ”
